Tuesday, March 18, 2008

Experiencing limitations should offer clues


The St. Louis Post-Dispatch reports on community leaders participating in simulated poverty and the frustrations even when days are only 15 minutes long. The Missouri Ozarks Community Action Agency prepares this exercise to give decision-makers and shapers the insight into what their communities offer for the least fortunate, and what it feels like to be part of the percentage that aren’t benefiting.

One participant looked for daycare vouchers for her child so she could go to school.

Understanding the roadblocks that families run into when they are trying to make ends meet is important as we try to make policies that help. Right now, Missouri is looking at passing Bryce’s Law: tuition tax credit scholarships for families of special needs children that would allow children to transfer to a school that will meet their specific needs—even if their parents can’t afford it. It’s no different from a day care voucher except that taxpayers wouldn’t pay for it: private donations would.

Many have criticized Bryce’s Law as parents seeking some sort of entitlement, which has raised my hackles. Giving parents the option to choose where their special needs child will be best served is their right, but currently that right is being filtered through a local IEP team. I believe that parents are qualified to have the final say about their child’s education. We place the responsibility of feeding them before school, getting them to and from school, and paying for all of the help they cannot find in public schools. The least we can do is give them access to a scholarship to offset costs and give them the flexibility to seek out an education that will really improve their child’s skills.

Some say that tax credits decrease general revenue, and with that funds for public education. The fact is that the program would be revenue neutral, akin to moving a savings account into another bank. It’s still being invested, but it’s been moved because the investor believes they’ll see a better return on their investment in the new bank. And it is that individual’s prerogative to choose the best account. You’ll notice we have many different types of investment options that offer choices to all kinds of needs, and that even the choice to switch banks comes after lots of research and comparison—how much more important is seeing a non-verbal child learn to speak, read, go to college and start their own savings account?

Furthermore, most of Missouri’s tax credits are not revenue-neutral, and no one is calling for their repeal because as much as we need funds for education, we also understand that redevelopment in struggling communities is right, and giving young mothers daycare so they can work or go to school is right, and helping small farmers stay in business is right. So, is providing assistance for families with disabled children right? Unequivocally YES.

No comments: